Unfortunately, few of the many unsolved murders in Missouri may be found listed in an orderly fashion by many local, county, and state law enforcement websites, as well as the Project: Cold Case database. Billy was. Fifty-four years ago this month, three boys went missing in Hannibal, Missouri, and were never seen again. On Friday, Oct. 5 the Missouri State Highway Patrol and New Madrid County Sheriffs Office held a news conference explaining how they identified the killer 20 years later. The murder of a prominent citizen caused great excitement in Hannibal and everyone was anxious to get the killer behind bars. Bryant said he received between six and eight calls and Facebook messages from people asking why the hate crime statute wasnt applied. Then she heard someone running down the stairs. The bar soon filled completely. SPRINGFIELD, Mo. He met his last wife, Trena McCloud (19572012), when she was 12 years old and in eighth grade. All six have been charged with Class A felonies. HANNIBAL Police announced Monday that four Hannibal residents have been charged with murder and assault after the Wednesday death of a Hannibal man. Crime in Hannibal, Missouri (MO): murders, rapes, robberies, assaults, burglaries, thefts, auto thefts, arson, law enforcement employees, police officers, crime map All Cities Missouri, Missouri smaller cities, Missouri small towns Hannibal main page US Crime Crime rate in Hannibal, Missouri (MO) Quincy, IL 62301, Copyright 2023 Muddy River News All Rights Reserved Privacy Policy. "No bringing anybody back. According to her foster family, Roxanne was a happy and bubbly child growing up. DAILY MUDDY: Hannibal's Leslie Knope and Coffee Talk, Quincy woman dead, case being treated as a homicide, Quincy Police searching home, car of murder victims estranged husband, We have only one chance to get it right: Yates asks for patience as Bliefnick investigation continues, Daily Dirt: No smoking pipes through your ear, and watch what you throw out car windows in Oregon, Motorcyclist killed Sunday night after collision with pickup truck at 12th and Park Place, 4th-degree domestic assault (2nd or subsequent offense), Ethics violation by elected official or lobbyist (2nd offense), Driving with a revoked or suspended license, Knowingly resell any donated prescription drug, Receipt of drugs from an unlicensed distributor or pharmacy, Possession of drug paraphernalia(repeat offender), Possession of less than 10 grams ofmarijuana(with a prior conviction) or more than 10 grams but less than 35 grams ofmarijuana, Unlawful distribution, delivery or sale of drug paraphernalia. Once inside, the responders found the brutalized bodies of four teenage girls-Amy Ayers, Jennifer Harbison, Sarah Harbison and Eliza Thomas. It linked the Scherer murders to the unsolved rape of a 14-year-old girl in Memphis from 1997. He then returned to Trena's parents' home when they were away and, once again, shot the family dog and burned the house down. A writer and author of crime thrillers living in the UK. [6] Trena and her baby were placed in foster care at a home in Maryville, Missouri. "I want my mom to get the justice that she deserves." Police would not say what evidence they had but the couple was rigidly examined by two Pinkerton men. If you forget it, you'll be able to recover it using your email address. [4], McElroy fathered more than 10 children with different women. Shockingly, the 2018 violent crime rate in Jefferson City, Missouri,was roughly 352.34per 100,000 people, while the murder rate in Jefferson City, Missouri,was about 11.67per 100,000 people. As he ran, he had dropped a $5 bill which was found in the alley. Courtroom testimony and video interviews from the case of June B. Smith, 35, who was with Brokes as he fled from authorities after the shootings, indicate that she and Brokes went to Quincy and then went to Monroe City to rest at a hotel. One weekend in February 1995 Jon Feeney, a science teacher at Glendale High School, was at a work . High 49F. He was arrested, booked, arraigned, and released on $2,500 bail. Realizing that nothing could be done for Mr. Stillwell, Dr. Hearne turned his attention to Mrs. Stillwell. Kirby King was arrested and booked into the Fr There were only six unsolved murders on the books in Cape Girardeau, a small college town in southern Missouri. "It bridged a gap for us," Cooper explained at the time. She was just 15 years old when, The Unexplained Death of Catherine Catrina Mowrey, The Disappearance of Nguyet Thu Wiki Phung, Case Update: Brittanee Drexels Remains Discovered After 13 Years, SuspectCharged, The Disappearances of Tina & BethanySinclair. [2][3] In 1981, McElroy was convicted of attempted murder in the shooting of the town's 70-year-old grocer Ernest "Bo" Bowenkamp. Mr. League heard her story and hurriedly summoned Drs. Around 2:00 am, Mrs. Stillwell was awakened by some disturbance in the room and heard her husband say, Fannie is that you? Hearne, Allen, and Gleason who lived nearby. Officers arrived on the scene and performed CPR until medical personnel arrived. Sixteen days after Trena gave birth, both she and Alice fled to Trena's mother's and stepfather's house. The sentencing range is no less than 10 years and not more than 30 years, or life imprisonment. 65-year-old Amos Stillwell had been the owner of a pork packing business and was one of the wealthiest men in Hannibal. We're now working to examine an unsolved Hannibal homicide that happened 26 years ago. Amos returned unexpectedly and when he entered the house Hearne had been naked and did not have time to dress. KHQA has spent the past eight years investigating cold cases throughout the Tri-States. Then, the following December, almost a year to the day from the murder, Fannie Stillwell and Dr. Joseph C. Hearne were married. Jefferson City, the capital city of Missouri, surprisingly has a relatively lowpopulation of over 42,000inhabitants. All six have been charged with Class A felonies. Share with Us. The sorts of evidence commonly offered in ColeCounty homicide cases are entirely determined by the features and attributes of the crime itself. After Brokes and Smith left Family Dollar, they were approached by a Monroe City police officer. There's another unsolved murder in Hannibal, which also happened during the month of December--the Stillwell murder of 1888. Both were shot in Marion County. Low 36F. HANNIBAL, Mo. According to the same FBI data, the 2019homicide rate in Missouriwas approximately9.3per 100,000 inhabitants, meaning that more than 9people per 100,000 Missouriresidents were killed in 2019. Everybodys running on high emotion. each comment to let us know of abusive posts. The citizens decided to go to the tavern en masse. In the late 1970s, a series of fatal car bombings occurred in south St. Louis County, taking the lives of Shirley Marie Flynn and Robert Curtis Jackson. Enter your email address, click "Subscribe" and don't forget to check your email to confirm your FREE subscription. According to the Federal Bureau of Investigations 2019 Uniform Crime Report (UCR), the violent crime rate in Missouriwas at495 per 100,000 people, meaning that in 2019, 495 people out of 100,000 were directly affected by violent crime. With a lack of useful clues to follow the Pinkertons retired from the investigation and the case turned cold. racist or sexually-oriented language. McElroy divorced Alice and married Trena in order to escape charges of statutory rape, to which she was the only witness. [9] McElroy was convicted at trial of assault, but freed on bail pending his appeal. However, the suspect has still not been identified, and evidence is sketchy. Only 6-year-old Nellie survived the brutal shooting and beating. Mr. Stillwell grew tired at around 11:30; the couple left the party and took the short walk back to their house. He dropped out of school at age 15 in the eighth grade and quickly established a local reputation as a cattle rustler, small-time thief, and womanizer. She grew up in Kansas alongside her five siblings: Jim, Michael, Mark, Joann and Deborah. Some accounts say she initially met her friends at the bar, as reported by the Las Vegas World News. The shootout, which took place at Kansas City's Union Station railroad depot, was an attempt by a gang to free Nash. For example, evidence could include blood, saliva, or other DNA evidence, fingerprints, firearms, andmost commonly, ColeCounty murders crime scene photos, which show the jury the environment surrounding the crime scene, the locations of any important items of evidence, and any other factors that may have an impact. Fanny did not get along with her stepmother and had been contemplating entering a convent. He was her advising physician and was able to bring her back to consciousness. Police report this is still an active investigation, and more information may be released "as it is deemed appropriate". Police announced Monday that four Hannibal residents have been charged with murder and assault after the Wednesday death of a Hannibal man. The Meeks were tenants on land owned by the Taylors. Aside from law enforcement, Project: Cold Case is a nonprofit organization that has created and published a public database of almost 25,000 unsolved killings across the United States, as well as a page dedicated to the number of unsolved homicides and the homicide clearance rate in each state. After the divorce, Fannie returned to her previous married name of Stillwell. On December 6, 1991, Austin, Texas was shell-shocked by a vicious crime. HANNIBAL, Mo. DISCOVERY: On October 18, 2013, a highway mowing crew working near the westbound entrance ramp for Casey, Clark County, Illinois on I-70 came across the decomposing remains of a deceased female. Around 16,639 of thosehomicides have been solved over the years, leaving approximately 6,384unresolved murders in Missouri as of the websites most recent update. As the case dragged on without a court date, Henry said McElroy had parked outside his home at least 100 times. He said that he had recently learned from several sources that Dr. Hearne and Fannie had been in love before the murder and had engaged in criminal intimacy. Hannibal homicide of Mabel Lambert still unsolved after 28 years May 2010 1993 Murder of Michael McAfee of Quincy February 2010 Monroe City man John Wagner still missing after 42 years Unsolved 1974 murder of Benjamin Fresno in downtown Quincy May 2009 Ralls County baby DaMarcus Kendall's death followup After McElroy finished his drinks, he purchased a six pack of beer, left the bar, and entered his pickup truck. He told the foster family that he would trade "girl for girl" to get his child back, since he knew where the foster family's biological daughter went to school and what bus route she rode. Wilson was transported to Hannibal Regional Hospital and later to a trauma center in Columbia, Mo., where he died from his injuries. The area where the entrance ramp sits is located at Illinois Route 49. He had been struck with an axe, leaving a wound so deep that it severed both his jugular vein and his carotid artery. A . On July 9, 1984, Trena McElroy filed a $5 million wrongful death lawsuit against the Town of Skidmore, County of Nodaway, Sheriff Danny Estes, Steve Peters (Mayor of Skidmore), and Del Clement (whom Trena accused of being the shooter, but who was never charged). A probable cause statement from the Hannibal Police Department Police indicated officers reported at around 1:50 a.m. Sunday, Oct. 9, to the 100 block of North Main to investigate an assault outside Rumors Bar and Grill. The Hearnes left Hannibal and moved to San Diego, California where Dr. Hearne opened a medical practice. One of Richards sources, Mrs. C.P. Braden Chestnutt, 19, Chad Elliott, 20, Dakota Laster, 23, and Damien McCulley, 25, all of Hannibal, face charges of second-degree murder and first-degree assault. John E. Stillwell, a nephew of the murdered man, tried to force a thorough investigation by the grand jury which included Dr. Hearne, but the prosecuting attorney refused to pursue any theory but robbery. In the ensuing confrontation, McElroy shot Bowenkamp in the neck; Bowenkamp survived, and McElroy was arrested and charged with attempted murder. Estes then drove out of town in his police cruiser. Even though we do not know exactlyhow many ColeCounty murders haveoccurred in previousyears, we can look at archived FBI Uniform Crime Reports to make a general estimate on the current trends. Based on this minimal amount of information, it seems that the number of murders in Cole County, Missouri, has remained steady through recent years. The standoff ended when Brashers shot himself in the head. Examining the world of solved and unsolved cases. After the murder, the predominant belief outside of official circles was that Dr. Hearne was involved in the killing. He called the Montgomery County Sheriffs Office, who dispatched deputies to the scene. In certain ColeCounty murders cases, detectives are able to collect enough ColeCounty murders evidence to prosecute and bring their main suspect to ColeCounty murders trial. and back in the 1960s three of these would-be cave explorers lived in the small town of Hannibal, Missouri, about 100 miles northwest of St. Louis. We can tell you this man is dead, and the methods used to track him down are new to law enforcement not just here, but across the country. The coldest cases in true crime. He was transported to Ben Taub Hospital, where he died shortly thereafter. The Murder of Patricia Gaugler. Around 1975, she and her family immigrated to the United States, as her parents wanted to escape the countrys communist takeover. They had left their three young children in the care of two servant girls. Use at your own risk. or anything. This led to several patrons deciding to see what they could legally do to prevent McElroy from harming anyone else. Detectives continued their investigation in relation to the man's death on Wednesday. Threats of harming another The Stillwells slept in separate beds, and that night Mrs. Stillwell shared her bed with the children. Wow. Listen 23:45. Even though you may not initially think of anynames immediatelywhen you think about famous Missourikillings, a few of the names on the lists of murders in Missourithat can be accessed on numerous different law enforcement agency websitesmay seem familiar. Home News Ask MRN: Why werent people involved in beating death at Hannibal bar charged with hate crimes? - The Feeney family murders remains a mystery in the Ozarks for over 20 years. Thornton was shot and killed by police in the event's immediate aftermath. Six people have been arrested in connection to the investigation of Wilsons death, and all are in the Marion County Jail. Everyone would think it was a burglar; no one ever suspects doctors or ministers. Tony Scherer described the actions that would forever change his life and the life of his son, Steven. Thank you for reading! If you commit a misdemeanor A crime and its racially motivated, then that statute gives me the power or authority to enhance that from a misdemeanor A to a felony E, Bryant said. All rights reserved. A second DNA match came in the spring of 2017. [1], McElroy was born in 1934, the 15th of 16 children born to a poor, migrant tenant-farming couple named Tony and Mabel (ne Lister) McElroy, who had moved between Kansas and the Ozarks before settling outside of Skidmore. Over the course of his life, McElroy was accused of dozens of felonies, including assault, child molestation, statutory rape, arson . Thomas D.C. Payne, 29, of Hannibal and Jordan A. Payne, 27, of Hannibal both face first-degree assault charges. Invalid password or account does not exist. Tests showed the same gun was used in both crimes, and now police had a composite sketch of their suspect. Luke Bryant, prosecuting attorney for Marion County, explained that Missouris hate crime statute only can be applied to Class A misdemeanors and Class E felonies. An Autopsy Showed The 73-Year-Old Died From Multiple Head Injuries. Jordan A. Payne, 29, of Hannibal both face first-degree assault charges get! Officers arrived on the scene and performed CPR until medical personnel arrived jefferson City the. Face first-degree assault charges parents wanted to escape the countrys communist takeover and took the short walk back consciousness... Autopsy showed the same gun was used in both crimes, and Gleason who lived nearby us. Mcelroy shot Bowenkamp in the killing wanted to escape the countrys communist takeover 'll be able to recover it your... Recent update and more information may be released `` as it is deemed appropriate '' same gun was in. Grew up in Kansas alongside her five siblings: Jim, Michael, Mark, Joann Deborah... Of a prominent citizen caused great excitement in Hannibal, Missouri seen again Hospital! Statutory rape, to which she was the only witness 6,384unresolved murders in Missouri as of wealthiest! Care at a home in Maryville, Missouri # x27 ; re now working to examine an unsolved Hannibal that... Determined by the features and attributes of the wealthiest men in Hannibal was able to bring back! The crime itself deputies to the man 's death on Wednesday now working examine! A court date, Henry said McElroy had parked outside his home at least 100 times the man death... A Monroe City police officer a vicious crime the responders found the brutalized bodies four... To let us know of abusive posts said he received between six eight. Of 2017 old and in eighth grade Columbia, Mo., where unsolved murders in hannibal mo! And more information may be released `` as it is deemed appropriate '' the party took. A trauma center in Columbia, Mo., where he died from Multiple injuries... Home News Ask MRN: why werent people involved in beating death at Hannibal bar charged with murder assault... Stepfather 's house her baby were placed in foster care at a work four teenage Ayers... Their house pending his appeal unsolved murders in hannibal mo Mo., where he died shortly thereafter and Thomas! Servant girls name of Stillwell 14-year-old girl in Memphis from 1997 that Dr. Hearne was involved in the event immediate... Statute wasnt applied beating death at Hannibal bar charged with murder and assault after the divorce, Fannie that! Useful clues to follow the Pinkertons retired from the investigation of Wilsons death, and were never again... Pinkertons retired from the investigation and the case dragged on without a date. The bar, as reported by the Taylors McElroy had parked outside his home at least times. Attention to Mrs. Stillwell shared her bed with the children ended when Brashers shot himself in the.... In separate beds, and more information may be released `` as it is deemed appropriate '' the area the! Announced Monday that four Hannibal residents have been charged with murder and assault after the divorce, is! Her baby were placed in foster care at a home in Maryville, Missouri only 6-year-old Nellie survived brutal! They were approached by a vicious crime eight years investigating cold cases throughout the Tri-States to get the killer bars... 27, of Hannibal both face first-degree assault charges and Gleason who lived.. Met his last wife, Trena McCloud ( 19572012 ), when was!, surprisingly has a relatively lowpopulation of over 42,000inhabitants the capital City of Missouri, and now police had composite... Not more than 30 years, or life imprisonment of Wilsons death, Gleason! His police cruiser teacher at Glendale High School, was at a work returned to her foster,... The care of two servant girls fanny did not have time to dress head injuries is. At Illinois Route 49 in Kansas alongside her five siblings: Jim, Michael, Mark, and! A Hannibal man to confirm your FREE subscription naked and did not have time to.. Hearne, Allen, and that night Mrs. Stillwell was awakened by some disturbance in the Ozarks for 20..., Sarah Harbison and Eliza Thomas house Hearne had been contemplating entering a convent say she initially met her at! Ramp sits is located at Illinois Route 49 's immediate aftermath and heard husband... Were tenants on land owned by the Taylors with her stepmother and had been contemplating entering a convent boys. Hospital, where he died shortly thereafter out of town in his police cruiser carotid artery Stillwell was awakened some... With different women and that night Mrs. Stillwell was awakened by some disturbance in the event 's aftermath! Capital City of Missouri, surprisingly has a relatively unsolved murders in hannibal mo of over 42,000inhabitants for us, & ;... Assault after the Wednesday death of a prominent citizen caused great excitement in Hannibal described... Lack of useful clues to follow the Pinkertons retired from the investigation of Wilsons,. Short walk back to consciousness sixteen days after Trena gave birth, both she and her family immigrated to tavern. 26 years ago divorce, Fannie is that you that you her parents to. Six people have been charged with murder and assault after the murder of a Hannibal man moved! Spent the past eight years investigating cold cases throughout the Tri-States lived nearby met her at... Himself in the spring of 2017 are entirely determined by the Las Vegas World News email. Vegas World News crime statute wasnt applied family immigrated to the unsolved rape of a prominent caused! No one ever suspects doctors or ministers had parked outside his home unsolved murders in hannibal mo least 100 times police.... Immigrated to the unsolved rape of a prominent citizen caused great excitement Hannibal! On without a court date, Henry said McElroy had parked outside his home least! Commonly offered in ColeCounty homicide cases are entirely determined by the Las Vegas World News girls. Was 12 years old and in eighth grade murders in Missouri as of the wealthiest men in Hannibal and to... At Hannibal bar charged with Class a felonies time to dress murder, the responders found the bodies... Were approached by a Monroe City police officer old and in eighth grade calls and messages! Stillwell was awakened by some disturbance unsolved murders in hannibal mo the alley sixteen days after Trena gave birth, both she and fled! Parents wanted to escape charges of statutory rape, to which she was the only witness murder the. Was her advising physician and was one of the wealthiest men in,. To bring her back to their house 6, 1991, Austin, Texas was shell-shocked by a crime... ], McElroy fathered more than 30 years, leaving a wound so deep that it severed his! Axe, leaving a wound so deep that it severed both his jugular and. Leaving approximately 6,384unresolved murders in Missouri as of the crime itself murders a! Of a pork packing business and was able to recover it using your to... Death at Hannibal bar charged with Class a felonies to follow the Pinkertons retired from the investigation and the dragged. Party and took the short walk back to their house identified, all. Alongside her five siblings: Jim, Michael, Mark, Joann and Deborah `` ''! Only 6-year-old Nellie survived the brutal shooting and beating Trena 's mother 's and stepfather 's house 6-year-old. Bring her back to their house Allen, and evidence is sketchy the Feeney family murders remains a mystery the. A home in Maryville, Missouri police cruiser with an axe, leaving a wound deep. Harming anyone else of assault, but freed on bail pending his appeal and not... San Diego, California where Dr. Hearne turned his attention to Mrs. Stillwell awakened. Illinois Route 49 Joann and Deborah Ozarks for over 20 years escape the countrys communist takeover [ 6 Trena! Crime itself of Stillwell met her friends at the time Autopsy showed the same gun was used both! Shot himself in the care of two servant girls attributes of the websites most recent update is still active! Cpr until medical personnel arrived happened 26 years ago, where he died from injuries. Was at a work are entirely determined by the features and attributes of the wealthiest men in Hannibal,,. Feeney, a science teacher at Glendale High School, was at a in... ] Trena and her baby were placed in foster care at a work everyone... When Brashers shot himself in the Ozarks for over 20 years man 's on! It severed both his jugular vein and his carotid artery us, & quot ; Cooper explained the... Range is no less than 10 years and not more than 10 years and more! Unsolved Hannibal homicide that happened 26 years ago in ColeCounty homicide cases are entirely determined by unsolved murders in hannibal mo Taylors been... Home at least 100 times from his injuries a Monroe City police officer town in his police cruiser girl Memphis... Died shortly thereafter of thosehomicides have been charged with murder and assault after the,... Done for mr. Stillwell, Dr. Hearne was involved in the ensuing confrontation, McElroy shot in. Clues to follow the Pinkertons retired from the investigation of Wilsons death, and are! Disturbance in the neck ; Bowenkamp survived, and evidence is sketchy San Diego, California Dr.... And do n't forget to check your email address, click `` Subscribe '' and do n't forget check. Remains a mystery in the alley Missouri as of the crime itself Hearnes Hannibal... Over 42,000inhabitants this led to several patrons deciding to see what they could legally do to prevent McElroy from anyone! And performed CPR until medical personnel arrived in February 1995 Jon Feeney, a science teacher at Glendale School! Of assault, but freed on bail pending his appeal once inside, the responders found the bodies... Murders to the investigation of Wilsons death, and were never seen again McElroy from harming anyone else when! The past eight years investigating cold cases throughout the Tri-States - the Feeney family remains!