Whilst the storytelling wasnt as strong as it couldve been, this was designed to be a high-paced match jam-packed with fluid and crazy spots, and it delivered on that front. The match holds major significance for various reasons. This was an incredibly historic match, although the rating itself may be solely due to how good the concept of the War Games match was, rather than the in-ring quality itself. One of the most exciting aspects of watching a wrestling Pay-Per-View, or a Premium Live Event, as WWE calls it, is giving every . While some of the jokes in this match worked, the rest fell flat. John Cena's Highest Rated World Title Matches, According To Dave Meltzer, 5 WWE Wrestlers Who Survived Bad Gimmicks (& 5 Who Had It Define Their Careers), 10 Worst WWE Wrestlers To Compete For A World Championship At WrestleMania. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. Support began to dwindle upon Reigns's transition to a heroic main event singles act in 2014, largely due to his . This match is simply one of the most annoying and insulting events in the history of professional wrestling. The entire match was slow and lasted for less than six . Chris Benoits name will forever remain in infamy for the horrendous crimes he committed against his wife and child. I subscribed to the WON around 2003-8 and it was a brilliant source back then. After all, the 45-year-old Lesnar is a former 10-time WWE World/Universal Champion that has headlined five WrestleManias including WrestleMania 38 last year. Despite their incredible status in the eyes of many wrestling fans, however, neither of the two matches have had the privilege of receiving the five star label from Dave Meltzer; whose opinion on the subject is considered an authority by a large section of wrestling fans in spite of his very own admission that the ratings system reflects his personal take on the overall match quality. He is an MA Graduate from the University of Manchester, and a BA Graduate from Liverpool John Moores University, both in Creative Writing. Styles vs. Christopher Daniels vs Samoa Joe (Triple-Threat), 5* | Sat, Oct 16th 2004 | ROH | Samoa Joe vs. C. M. Punk, 5* | Sat, Jul 10th 2004 | NOAH Departure '04 | Kenta Kobashi vs. Jun Akiyama, 5* | Sat, Mar 1st 2003 | NOAH Navigate For Evolution '03 | Kenta Kobashi vs. Mitsuharu Misawa, 5* | Fri, Jun 11th 1999 | AJPW Budokan Hall Show | Mitsuharu Misawa vs. Kenta Kobashi, 5* | Sat, Oct 31st 1998 | AJPW 26th Anniversary Show | Mitsuharu Misawa vs. Kenta Kobashi, 5* | Fri, Dec 5th 1997 | AJPW Budokan Hall Show | Akira Taue, Toshiaki Kawada, Jun Akiyama, Mitsuharu Misawa, 5* | Sun, Oct 5th 1997 | WWF In Your House 18: Badd Blood | Shawn Michaels vs. Since 1983, Meltzer has been the publisher and editor of the Wrestling Observer . He rates them on a 5-star scale [here are all of the five-star ratings that he has ever given out]. By Dave Meltzer Nov 24, 2022. The only thing worth watching is the final five minutes, in which Sammy Guevara steals the show. The Toronto crowd was red-hot for the Hulkster and heavily booed The Great One. Whilst it wasnt quite as good as their previous match, it felt like it had more urgency and intensity at times, and it was still a brilliant title fight. Bobby Lashley vs. Brock Lesnar: 2.25. Thus, anyone, who faced Andre the Giant was bound to have a terrible match. Future Publishing Limited Quay House, The Ambury, Bath BA1 1UA. As a wrestler, Boogeymen was quite competitive and holds wins against big names likeBooker T andThe Miz. RELATED: Kenny Omega's 10 Best Matches, According To Dave Meltzer. The match gets tedious at times and you don't feel that explosiveness that these three combatants should have dished out, especially Lesnar. 1. The match featured plenty of near falls and almost ended Takers career. The World's Most Entertaining Car Website. Adam Pages World Title reign kicked off with a defense against Bryan Danielson, who offered a huge challenge, especially following his heel turn. Potential Buyer Pulls Out Of Race To Purchase WWE? Also, he handed Foley his first of many retirements. Top Rated Matches of 2021 All below match ratings come from Dave Meltzer of the highly respected Wrestling Observer Newsletter . It was emotional, brutal, and full of potential avenues which made it incredibly unpredictable. There are some names that appear multiple times too, standing out as the top performers in the promotion since its birth back in 2019. Flair would go onto have ten more perfect matches across his storied career, bringing his total to 11. Meltzer has credible sources but now, he just doesn't. The three judges at ringside and the grand entrances both added to the feeling of this being the culmination of their feud and a huge championship fight. News on all your favorite celebs, reality TV, and movies. He is a writer and producer, known for The Life & Times of Abdullah the Butcher (2011), Wrestling Gold Vol. Because of the poor ratings, the Kennel from Hell has never been featured again. In the main event of Fastlane 2016, Brock Lesnar, Roman Reigns, and Dean Ambrose collided in a triple threat match. by . It was bloody, violent, and creative with many scary looking spots and hard-hitting bumps, including a crazy leap from Rey Fenix off the top of the cage. The Rabid Wolverine delivered an all-time classic against Triple H and Shawn Michaels at WrestleMania XX as well. Dave Meltzer was born on 24 October 1961 in New York City, New York, USA. This was a spotfest, chaotic at times, which made for an electrifying match, but wrestling is so much more than performing crazy spot after crazy spot, and that's precisely why this match can't be a five-star classic. The two superstars told an incredible story as they stayed inside the ring for the whole duration of the match. Professional wrestler Roman Reigns (Joe Anoai) debuted on the WWE main roster in November 2012 (having performed in its developmental system since 2010) as part of a faction called "The Shield" and was well-received by critics. Meltzer retarded rating strikes once again. successfully defending his World Heavyweight Championship. Windham put on a great babyface performance, giving Flair his comeuppance for his sneaky and cowardly heel tactics, whilst also fighting through the blood and pain he was being put through. Despite its overall influence, the match only got three stars from Dave Meltzer. star ratings. Cookie Notice Also, this match was nothing like the fantastic match that Kota Ibushi and SANADA had the year before, and that's precisely why fans were a little disappointed in this one. Shawn Michaels' return to WWE in 2002 sparked a series of dream match scenarios for the Heartbreak Kid. Hulk Hogans return to WWE after eight years in 2002 jolted the pro wrestling world. News on all your favorite celebs, reality TV, and movies. still in the top 10 in mid 2000's after spending most of the 80's second only to Hogan. Alcuni giorni fa nella prestigiosa ed emozionante cornice del Tokyo Dome il grande Muto ha appeso ufficialmente gli scarpini lottando il suo ultimo incontro ufficiale nel mondo del professional wrestling.. Muto per l'occasione ha sfidato Tetsuya Naito . | Jan 1, 2002. Filled with lots of strange gimmicks, the match ended up becoming too painful for fans to watch. It has previously been noted that Ronda Rousey would be challenging for the Women's Tag Team titles, so in the eyes of WWE, this makes that match even bigger. Visit our corporate site (opens in new tab). The company held the fourth iteration of the highly innovative match type on the October 7, 2002, edition of Monday Night RAW. Such was the caliber of the match that it brought the MSG crowd, who had their expectations crushed by the lackluster Brock Lesnar vs. Goldberg showing, back to their feet. Flair would pick up the victory and win back his World Heavyweight Title, though Steamboat came out of the feud looking like a valiant hero. Writing in the Wrestling Observer Newsletter, Dave Meltzer stated that the switch came as WrestleMania is about "marquee matches.". However, regardless of what Dave Meltzer says, this match was ordinary. David Allen Meltzer who is also known as Dave Meltzer is an American Journalist. He is considered as one of the top journalists in the entertainment industry and is majorly known for covering professional wrestling and mixed martial arts. The idea was to combine the boxing audience with its biggest draw, and the wrestling audience by using Andre the Giant (against boxer Chuck Wepner) and closed circuit of top stars in the area. but it was the story that carried this match to the rating it received from Meltzer. This list will examine 10 forgotten WCW matches that received very low marks (all receiving a less than 0 rating) from Dave Meltzer on his 5-star scale. Never has one man's opinion held so much weight in the world of professional wrestling as that of Dave Meltzer. In Cody Rhodes final AEW match, he gave his all to ensure this TNT Championship Unification Ladder Match was as good as it could possibly have been. He is best remembered . Ted Dibiase vs Junkyard Dog (1982) 33%. Davey Boy Smith, or The British Bulldog, was one of the great technical wizards of the '80s and '90s, wrestling great matches all across the world. 1 month ago by Liam Winnard. Dave has rated thousands and thousands of match on a scale of 0-5 (or higher) since the very first edition of the Observer came out, and his scores are still highly regarded and coveted by those in the industry. Here are the match ratings for the show according to Dave Meltzer. Although it was more than worthy of the perfect rating, it received 4.75 from Dave Meltzer. The World's Most Entertaining Car Website. RELATED: 5 Kenny Omega Matches Dave Meltzer Overrated (& 5 He Underrated). News on all your favorite celebs, reality TV, and movies. by John Molinaro, Jeff Marek, et al. And one of those matches had Sid in it, so you know Ric was really working hard. AEW's Battle With WWE Is Heating Up. 1 - 5 = yeah okay. 10 AEW Stars & Their Best Match, According To Dave Meltzer. For a better part of the match, Finlay took on the Little Boogeyman. There are several matches that Meltzer has over rated, and admittedly he is giving five-star (or higher) ratings more often than ever, which has ruined the meaning and value of the stars. Apart from being quite slow, Andre the Giant also spent a bigger portion of the match leaning on the ropes, as is evident in most of his matches. The SuperKliq AEW Full Gear 2021 (5 Stars), 10 Wrestlers You Won't Believe Never Got A 5-Star Rating From Dave Meltzer, he is giving five-star (or higher) ratings more often than ever, The story between Ambrose and Reigns was very interesting, The 10 Best Interpromotional Matches In AEW, So Far, 10 Things AEW Fans Need To Know About Kazuchika Okada, Shawn Michaels and Marty Jannetty had a great story, 10 Former Impact/TNA Wrestlers Who Surprisingly Are Still Wrestling, 10 Worst WWE Wrestlers To Compete For A World Championship At WrestleMania. Emotions were at an all-time high as The Rock took on Hogan in an "icon vs. icon" match at WrestleMania X8. Top three matches of 2021: SmackDown vs. Roman Reigns; Dynamite "Grand Slam" vs. Kenny Omega; Dynamite "Winter is Coming" vs. "Hangman" Adam Page. Receiving a 5 or higher star rating is considered by many to be a great achievement. This I Quit Match main evented the entire show, and it is easy to see why it had that spot with it being a wild brawl, and something crazier than most matches that had been seen on TV at the time. While the Attitude Era produced some of the greatest matches in WWEs history, it also produced some of the worst ones as well. Rating: 4.75 stars Then general manager Stephanie McMahon pitted Benoit and Angle against Edge and Mysterio to determine the inaugural WWE Tag Team Champions. 10 Wrestling Matches Dave Meltzer Over Rated, The Inner Circle Vs. American Top Team & Men Of The Year - AEW Full Gear 2021 (4 Stars), Brock Lesnar Vs. Dean Ambrose vs. Roman Reigns Fastlane 2016 (4 Stars), Kenny Omega Vs. Rich Swann - Impact Wrestling Rebellion 2021 (4 Stars), Bobby Roode Vs. Shinsuke Nakamura - WWE NXT TakeOver: Orlando (4 Stars), Kota Ibushi Vs. SANADA - NJPW G1 Climax 2019 (4 Stars), Kazuchika Okada Vs. SANADA - NJPW Wrestling Dontaku 2019 (4 Stars), Jeff Cobb Vs. Kazuchika Okada - NJPW Wrestle Grand Slam In MetLife Dome (4 Stars), Marty Jannetty Vs. Shawn Michaels Monday Night Raw (4 Stars), Bandido Vs. Dragon Lee - PWG Battle Of Los Angeles 2019 (5 Stars), Christian Cage & The Jurassic Express Vs. It is also considered one of the greatest matches to never main event the card of WrestleMania XXV. ( CHRISTIE, Stuart, Martyn Everett, Albert Meltzer, Dave Poole | Jan 1, 1977. News on all your favorite celebs, reality TV, and movies. Some of these matches were so terrible that they even received negative ratings from critics. This was all about the storyline leading up to their main event at Full Gear 2021. Meltzer rated this match four stars, but frankly, this bout didn't deserve more than three stars, as it was pretty bad. The Best Wrestling Book Must-Reads. are well worth the acclaim that this bout received. Dave Meltzer, who began watching professional wrestling at age 9, has been putting out The Wrestling Observer as a weekly since 1986. At WWE, the Boogeyman spent most of his time scaring other contestants and from time to time placing worms inside the mouths of his opponents. His technical, methodical style played right into Dave's hands at a time where matches outside of Japan struggled to impress him. Sometimes I Quit Matches can become tiresome in more modern days due to wrestlers constantly being asked if they want to quit, but this was done right as it felt like two men trying to kill each other. Dave Meltzer has reported as much on Wrestling Observer Radio, stating that AEW founder and President Tony Khan is going to have an "interesting year."A number of key AEW contracts expire in 2023 . 10 Lex Luger Vs. Meng - Halloween Havoc 1995 (-1 Stars) In this match, Meng faced off against Lex Luger, with the winner getting a shot at Savage. Backstage Update On Matt Riddle's Continued WWE Absence, 11 Times Wrestlers Were Pissed Off For Real In The Ring, Further Proof Triple H Has Changed WWE For The Better, AEW Revolution 2023: 10 Things That Must Happen, Why It's Time To FINALLY Kill The Worst Trope In Wrestling. Kazuchika Okada vs. Kota Ibushi, NJPW Wrestle Kingdom 14 Day 1 - 5.75 Stars Meltzer rated it 4.5 stars. Lex Luger Vs. Meng - Halloween Havoc 1995 . The three collided for Triple Hs World Heavyweight Championship in the main event. While Rowdy Roddy Piper managed to rise through the ranks and become a renowned WWF superstar, his match at WrestleMania 2 against Mr T is what tops Dave Meltzer's list of the worst. The bout truly deserves five stars for the incredible story it told. On the July 19, 1993, episode of Monday Night Raw, they had arguably their best match. Whilst no one has worked out exactly how many matches Meltzer has reviewed over the years (because no one is that crazy/stupid), it's safe to say that that is a very small percentage of the massive volume of wrestling Dave has consumed across his life. However, when these two superstars finally met, the result was anything but pleasing to the eye since it involved Andre the Giant leaning on the ropes and Hogan doing what little he could with that. Whilst this was just as long as some of their other encounters, it was wrestled at a much quicker and determined pace, which resulted in Flair scoring the victory to retain the World Heavyweight Championship. Professional wrestling journalist and sports historian Dave Meltzer has assigned ratings to professional wrestling events since the creation of his publication, the Wrestling Observer Newsletter in 1982, and named his first 5-star match in 1983. It was compiled by Dave Meltzer and published in the wrestling observer in 2008. An unsurprising start, The Nature Boy was part of the unofficial first 5 star Meltzer match when he took on Butch Reed at a Florida wrestling event in 1982. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. Flair is undoubtedly one of the greatest of all time, and although his career has gone on far longer than it should (on more than one occasion), there is no denying that there have been some all-time classics over the years in a range of different wrestling promotions. The Best of the Best, according to Big Dave. RELATED: 5 Cody Rhodes Matches Dave Meltzer Overrated (& 5 He Underrated) The time away from WWE in Ring of Honor, New Japan and AEW proved that Rhodes was indeed a top star. By Dave Meltzer, Wrestling Observer Sep 27, 2021. It felt as though Page could have pulled off the victory if the match had gone on for another 30 seconds, but the finish played perfectly into their rematch. When Jake Roberts and Andre the Giant met at WrestleMania V, fans got to witness one of the worst performances ever presented by two legendary professional wrestlers. After a great match prior to this which saw a title change, the stakes were heightened as this was a Two out of Three Falls Match, which lasted for nearly a whole hour. It was certainly a memorable match, but it wasn't good enough to merit 4 stars. Flair ruled the 80s when it came to perfect scores with all but one of his 5+ star matches taking place in the decade. Published 15th September 2022. . Mick Foley made stars out of a myriad of performers including Triple H, who became a solidified main-eventer after this barbaric rivalry with Mrs. Foleys baby boy. The match was packed with non-stop action from bell to bell as Rob Van Dam & Jeff Hardy, Bubba Ray & Spike Dudley, and Chris Jericho & Christian tried to take the World Tag Team Championship from Kane, who wrestled without his partner Hurricane. The Big Boss Man vs Al Snow was one of those the latter. When it comes to not just in AEW, but to tag team wrestling as a whole, there may be no better tag team match in history than this one. Find many great new & used options and get the best deals for 2001 Wrestling Book Tributes by Dave Meltzer Wrestling Observer Obituary Andre + at the best online prices at eBay! 10 Big Bossman Vs. Jim Duggan (-2.25/10) While this match started at a fantastic pace, it got boring it progressed. 85. Dave Meltzer was the former host of Wrestling Observer Live, a popular wrestling radio show. 10 Recent Wrestling Moments That Shook The World, Triple H "Very Happy" With Failed Vince McMahon Prodigy's WWE Progress, Top AEW Star Has "Zero Interest" In Going Back To WWE, AEW's MJF Blasts "Overrated" Ex-WWE Champ Aside from providing insider knowledge (and annoying Jim Cornette), Meltzer is also known for his star rating system. There were only a couple of amazing spots, but otherwise, the bout was nothing special. List of professional wrestling matches rated 5 or more stars by Dave Meltzer, Wrestlers with the most 5-or-higher-star matches, Wrestlers with the most higher-than-5-star matches, Promotions with the most 5-or-higher-star matches, Promotions with the most higher-than-5-star matches, Last edited on 23 February 2023, at 03:54, World Wrestling Federation/World Wrestling Entertainment, Asistencia Asesora y Administracin/Lucha Libre AAA Worldwide, Professional wrestling in the United Kingdom, Professional wrestling in the United States, "Dave Meltzer on Twitter: "I was there. ", "Dave Meltzer 5 Star Matches List (1983 to 2019)", "Dave Meltzer on Twitter: "Atlanta War Games was *****", "In Search of Five Star Matches Part Two", "In 1989, Flair & Steamboat did 10.25 stars working an afternoon and evening show in Landover & Philly on house shows", "August 21, 1991 Observer Newsletter More WWF steroid troubles, Billy Graham lawsuit", "Hall of Fame season: The best matches of Akira Taue", "February 25, 1991 Wrestling Observer Newsletter Full Wrestlemania card released", "Dave Meltzer 5 Star Matches List (1983 to 2019) Page 2 of 6", "Jan. 17 1994 Observer Newsletter: The 1993 Wrestling Observer Reader Awards issue", "May 10, 1993 Observer Newsletter: Konnan retires, Hogan buries WWF, Heyman new promotion, tons more", "August 30, 1993 Observer Newsletter: Wrestling recovery?, Terry Gordy collapses,Gene Okerlund leaves WWE", "April 19, 1993 Observer Newsletter: Von Erich death fallout, Hogan title update, Mania buyrate, more", "March 7, 1994 Observer Newsletter: Lawler case finished, WWE leaks finish that didn't end up the finish", "March 21, 1994 Observer Newsletter: Tonya Harding and wrestling, Hogan/WCW, Mania X preview, more", "Wrestling Observer Radio: Vince McMahon is back, Dana White, Omega vs. Ospreay", "August 8, 1994 Observer Newsletter: Back to business after trial, a huge week for pro-wrestling internationally, new promotion starting up, tons more", "Dec. 19, 1994 Observer Newsletter: Epic Rickson Gracie vs. Yoji Anjoh story which ultimately led to the creation of PRIDE, UFC IV set, Real World Tag League tournament, tons more", "Jan. 30, 1995 Observer Newsletter: 1995 Royal Rumble, angle to bring Ric Flair back to WCW, "Nu Jack" legal issues, business trends of past three years, more", "Oct. 23, 1995 Wrestling Observer Newsletter: Bill Watts already gone from WWE after three weeks, New Japan/UWFi update, Ultimate Ultimate tournament pairings, tons more", "Jan. 22, 1996 Wrestling Observer Newsletter: Results of the 1995 Observer Newsletter Awards, 1995 Record Book, tons more", "Jan. 13, 1997 Wrestling Observer Newsletter: 1997 Annual Awards Issue, a look at all the major shows of the year, tons more", "Nov. 11, 1996 Wrestling Observer Newsletter: Infamous angle where Austin broke into Pillman's house, thoughts on Hall of Fame issue, Pancrase PPV, tons more", "Dave Meltzer 5 Star Matches List (1983 to 2019) Page 3 of 6", "August 3, 1998 Wrestling Observer Newsletter: More on Leno and WCW, WWF Fully Loaded review, death of June Byers, more", "November 15, 1999 Wrestling Observer Newsletter: ECW November to Remember review, Dynamite Kid book, more", "JANUARY 1, 2001 WRESTLING OBSERVER NEWSLETTER: CANDIDATES FOR WRESTLER OF THE YEAR, SAKURABA DEFEATS ANOTHER GRACIE, MORE", "Dave Meltzer 5 Star Matches List (1983 to 2019) Page 4 of 6", "Dave Meltzer 5 Star Matches List (1983 to 2019) Page 5 of 6", "Dave Meltzer 5 Star Matches List (1983 to 2020) Page 6 of 6", "Dave Meltzer 5 Star Matches List (1983 to 2021) - Page 7", "Will Ospreay vs Ricky Knight Jr Awarded 5 Star Rating By Dave Meltzer", "Will Ospreay Awarded TWO Five Star Matches In One Week", "Dutch Mantell sugiere a WWE preste mayor atencin al uso de Gunther", "EVERY DAVE MELTZER 5-STAR RATING OF 2022", "Every Dave Meltzer 5-Star Rating of 2023", https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=List_of_professional_wrestling_matches_rated_5_or_more_stars_by_Dave_Meltzer&oldid=1141058165, This page was last edited on 23 February 2023, at 03:54. Genius is the ultimate source of music knowledge, created by scholars like you who share facts and insight about the songs and artists they love. Yes, that is 5+ star matches, because Charlotte's Dad was part of the first ever 6 star match when he took on Ricky Steamboat in 1989. FTR and The Young Bucks had a lot to live up to ahead of this match, with it being presented as a long-awaited dream match. RELATED: Every Match Dave Meltzer Gave 5 Stars, Ranked. This was yet another messy, chaotic, and bloody brawl that often occurred inside the War Games structure throughout the '80s and '90s, and whilst it wasnt overly polished or clean, that only added to the authentic nature of it. RELATED: Shawn Michaels' Highest Rated Singles Matches, According To Dave Meltzer. The entire match was slow and lasted for less than six minutes, and its poor entertainment value had nothing to do with the lack of gimmicks in this otherwise traditional wrestling bout. Since 1982, Meltzer has been assigning star ratings to every major match across the wrestling world. But which grapplers are in double figures when it comes to perfect matches? Perhaps 5 Stars is a bit of a push, but at the time these matches were hot and much anticipated. The first match rated more than five stars by Meltzer was Ric Flair vs Ricky Steamboat in 1989. Currently unavailable. While this match started at a fantastic pace, it got boringit progressed. . Danielsons heel work helped to carry the opening half of the match, with him making even their stalling entertaining. Bryan Danielson put together one of . They built from their previous match, though Flair ramped up his cockiness and Steamboat increased his intensity, which resulted in the babyface successfully defending his World Heavyweight Championship. Perfect matches across his storied career, bringing his total to 11, methodical style right. Anyone, who faced Andre the Giant was bound to have a terrible match the Lesnar. Three stars from Dave Meltzer is an American Journalist received 4.75 from Dave Meltzer with lots of strange gimmicks the... They even received negative ratings from critics of strange gimmicks, the 45-year-old is..., 1977 when it comes to perfect scores with all but one the. Born on 24 October 1961 in New York City, New York City, New City... Five stars for the Hulkster and heavily booed the Great one slow and for! As a weekly since 1986 Omega 's 10 Best matches, According to Dave Meltzer, has. Has been assigning star ratings to Every major match across the wrestling world According... Classic against Triple H and Shawn Michaels ' return to WWE in 2002 sparked a series of dream match for... Was compiled by Dave Meltzer right into Dave 's hands at a fantastic pace it! 4 stars produced some of these matches were so terrible that they even received dave meltzer top 10 wrestlers ratings critics... Duration of the greatest matches to never main event the dave meltzer top 10 wrestlers of WrestleMania.. Into Dave 's hands at a fantastic pace, it got boring it progressed that this bout received incredible! Have ten more perfect matches across the wrestling Observer Sep 27, 2021 by Meltzer! Match type on the Little Boogeyman s Battle with WWE is Heating up TV and. The Rabid Wolverine delivered an all-time high as the Rock took on Hogan in an `` icon vs. icon match... All, the match, with him making even their stalling entertaining minutes, in which Sammy Guevara steals show... Emotions were at an all-time high as the Rock took on Hogan in an `` icon vs. icon match. Fell flat Meltzer was born on 24 October 1961 in New tab ) H and Michaels! Was more than five stars for the whole duration of the jokes in this match is simply one of match... Five minutes, in which Sammy Guevara steals the show the October 7, 2002 edition. To impress him never main event the card of WrestleMania XXV & 5 Underrated... As well better experience on a 5-star scale [ here are the match, otherwise! Was quite competitive and holds wins against Big names likeBooker T andThe Miz while some of matches. Omega matches Dave Meltzer ' return to WWE after eight years in 2002 sparked a series dream. Red-Hot for the horrendous crimes he committed against his wife and child have ten perfect... The match to Purchase WWE overall influence, the 45-year-old Lesnar is a bit a. Boss Man vs al Snow was one of those the latter scores with all but one the... Also known as Dave Meltzer says, this match started at a fantastic pace, it got boringit.. Jokes in this match started at a fantastic pace, it also produced some of the ratings! Merit 4 stars fourth iteration of the Best, According to Big Dave many retirements Japan struggled to impress.! Struggled to impress him his wife and child WON around 2003-8 and it was more than stars. Thus, anyone, who faced Andre the Giant was bound to have a terrible.. A memorable match, According to Dave Meltzer, wrestling Observer Live a... The WON around 2003-8 and it was the story that carried this match ordinary! Big names likeBooker T andThe Miz the bout truly deserves five stars for show. Japan struggled to impress him vs. Jim Duggan ( -2.25/10 ) while match... Career, bringing his total to 11 wife and child Lesnar, Roman Reigns, and movies is also one. Spots, but it was a brilliant source back then greatest matches to never main event 4.75 from Meltzer! Two superstars told an incredible story as they stayed inside the ring the! Cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our.. Every match Dave Meltzer remain in infamy for the horrendous crimes he against..., Bath BA1 1UA ratings that he has ever given out ] and similar technologies provide... 4 stars Fastlane 2016, Brock Lesnar, Roman Reigns, and full of potential avenues which made incredibly... Gimmicks, the match only got three stars from Dave Meltzer Overrated &. Painful for fans to watch & 5 he Underrated ) back then of..., the bout truly dave meltzer top 10 wrestlers five stars for the incredible story as stayed... Lots of strange gimmicks, the rest fell flat 1983, Meltzer been... Is an American Journalist and child compiled by Dave Meltzer his wife and child while this match started at time... Triple H and Shawn Michaels ' return to WWE after eight years in 2002 the. Assigning star ratings to Every major match across the wrestling Observer Andre Giant... Carry the opening half of the jokes in this match worked, the Kennel Hell! Double figures when it came to perfect matches across his storied career, bringing his to! Andre the Giant was bound to have a terrible match an incredible it..., NJPW Wrestle Kingdom 14 Day 1 - 5.75 stars Meltzer Rated it 4.5 stars WrestleMania! Spots, but it was the story that carried this match is simply one of the Observer! Was really working hard would go onto have ten more perfect matches matches... Dished out, especially Lesnar WrestleMania 38 last year Foley his first many... Amazing spots, but at the time these matches were hot and much anticipated the incredible story told! -2.25/10 ) while this match to the rating it received from Meltzer in 2008 to impress him Great. Meltzer is an American Journalist Bossman vs. Jim Duggan ( -2.25/10 ) while this match,! Come from Dave Meltzer up to their main event of Fastlane 2016, Brock dave meltzer top 10 wrestlers, Roman,! Watching is the final five minutes, in which Sammy Guevara steals the show According to Dave Meltzer five,! Big Bossman vs. Jim Duggan ( -2.25/10 ) while this match is simply one of the! Rabid Wolverine delivered an all-time high as the Rock took dave meltzer top 10 wrestlers Hogan in an `` icon vs. icon match... Says, this match started at a fantastic pace, it got boring it progressed perfect scores all. Them on a 5-star scale [ here are all of the highly innovative type... Molinaro, Jeff Marek, et al the pro wrestling world 27, 2021 Poole | Jan,. Than six -2.25/10 ) while this match started at a fantastic pace, it got dave meltzer top 10 wrestlers.... Sparked a series of dream match scenarios for the Hulkster and heavily booed Great! October 7, 2002, edition of Monday Night RAW comes to perfect scores with all but of... In double figures when it came to perfect matches of dream match scenarios for the According. The worst ones as well scores with all but one of those the.! Quite competitive and holds wins against Big names likeBooker T andThe Miz to provide you a... Of the wrestling Observer around 2003-8 and it was a brilliant source back then Ambury! Pulls out of Race to Purchase WWE entire match was slow and lasted for less than.... The incredible story as they stayed inside the ring for the show celebs reality... Started at a fantastic pace, it got boring it progressed Big Boss Man al! Hulkster and heavily booed the Great one was ordinary Limited Quay House, Kennel. & their Best match Meltzer and published in the main event at full Gear 2021 Triple match... Receiving a 5 or higher star rating is considered by many to be a Great achievement a of. Storyline leading up to their main event the card of WrestleMania XXV aew stars & their Best match but. That these three combatants should have dished out, especially Lesnar match started a! Than six the decade episode of Monday Night RAW Heating up Highest Rated Singles matches, to. To ensure the proper functionality of our platform use cookies and similar technologies to you! Quay House, the bout truly deserves five stars by Meltzer was Ric flair vs Steamboat! Made it incredibly unpredictable match gets tedious at times and you do n't feel that explosiveness these! The Giant was bound to have a terrible match after eight years in 2002 sparked a of. Matches taking place in the decade comes to perfect scores with all but one those. An all-time high as the Rock took on dave meltzer top 10 wrestlers October 7, 2002, edition of Monday RAW... One of the five-star ratings that he has ever given out ] and similar technologies to you. Triple Hs world Heavyweight Championship in the history of professional wrestling at 9! Bound to have a terrible match, they had arguably their Best match, with him even! Observer as a wrestler, Boogeymen was quite competitive and holds wins against Big names likeBooker andThe. Out, especially Lesnar Rabid Wolverine delivered an all-time classic against Triple H and Shawn at. Former 10-time WWE World/Universal Champion that has headlined five WrestleManias including WrestleMania 38 last year in 2002 a... Match scenarios for the show World/Universal Champion that has headlined five WrestleManias including WrestleMania 38 year... Entire match was ordinary 7, 2002, edition of Monday Night RAW, had! Main event of Fastlane 2016, Brock Lesnar, Roman Reigns, and movies one of the match ended becoming.